You Don’t Want to Know
A Part of me kept me small for fifty years, guarding me from rejection. One morning I thanked him and asked him to guard against something more dangerous: the verdicts my own mind hands down.
On the Part of me that kept me small, and the job I asked him to do instead.
The Part of me that has kept me small for most of my life was born in early childhood. Until I was eleven, I lived with a father whose temper was unpredictable and violent, in a family where the safest thing a boy could be was quiet and out of the way. I learned that early, and I learned it well. Being small wasn’t a personality trait so much as the way I learned to stay safe.
Then my parents divorced, and for the next four years my sisters and I lived on a farm in rural West Virginia, far enough out that the school bus ride to middle school was eleven miles. They were the only safe years of my childhood, and the longest I would live at one address until I was past thirty. I had a horse, a motorcycle, a drum set and forests to roam, and we had the run of the place. With little left to guard against, the Part grew quiet, and I got to experience life without his constant vigilance. I was confident, relaxed, comfortable in my own skin, and happy. I was big.
In ninth grade, still on the farm and still big, I ran for class president, at a school where I had known most of my classmates for more than three years. I lost. Big. When I asked the school administration, who counted the ballots, how many votes I’d gotten, they told me, “You don’t want to know.” I never did learn the number. Apparently it was that bad.
The election rejection was just the beginning. Soon after, my mother announced she was remarrying, which meant leaving the farm. We sold the horses, the motorcycle, the drum set, nearly everything that had made that life what it was, and moved into town, to the house of a stepfather who didn’t want me there. At my new school, I didn’t know a single person. It was a return to scary. It was also the first of three moves during my high school years.
None of that was exactly a repeat of my early childhood. It didn’t have to be. Looking back, an election verdict from people I had known for years, the loss of the only place I had ever felt safe, and a new home run by a man whose facial expressions made clear he didn’t particularly care for me looked familiar enough. My Part came back with everything he had, this time for the long game. That’s how protectors roll: they don’t need the danger to return, only something that resembles it. I went from big to quiet, reserved and careful about what other people thought of me. I learned to be small again, because small doesn’t get noticed, and what doesn’t get noticed doesn’t get rejected, or attacked.
That strategy went with me through high school, college and the rest of my adult life. Whatever protection it once gave me came at a higher price every year. And there was plenty more rejection along the way: a college scholarship I really wanted and didn’t get, a marriage that ended painfully, a military career that ended much differently than I’d expected. Much of it was truly devastating, and being small prevented none of it. What it did was limit what I was willing to attempt next, and the attempts I didn’t make, or made halfway, produced their own disappointments, each one fresh evidence for the Part that putting myself out there wasn’t safe. Quite a system, and I never consciously chose any of it. I was simply being protected by a Part I didn’t see, and judging myself as self-sabotaging.
I’m sixty-five now. I’ve just published my first book, MIND CONTROL, and promoting it means writing in public, talking on podcasts, making videos and asking people to read my work: making myself visible to a world that is free to say no. I’ve come a long way, and the Part is still there, and the pull to shrink is getting in the way of something that matters a great deal to me. I want to be big again, and I need to be. By big I don’t mean important or famous. I mean showing up as fully as I am, without pulling back in advance because someone might disapprove.
Which brings me to my journal one morning recently. In MIND CONTROL I call protective patterns like this one Parts: fragments of identity that formed when we were overwhelmed, each holding its own beliefs about what is dangerous and what has to be done about it. I call this one Mr. Protector Part, and that morning I was working with him the way Chapter 8 of the book describes. I’ve known for years what he was doing. What I saw that morning was that he had been protecting me from the wrong thing.
Rejection hurt, and some of it cost me things I still feel. But the pain of a rejection and the meaning I made of it are two different things, and the meaning is what did the lasting damage. Many rejections amount to someone saying you’re not for me, right now, and even the ones that were far more than that couldn’t settle anything about my worth. What happened next was something else. I’m not good enough. People don’t choose me. If I put myself out there, I’ll only get hurt again. Those stories became beliefs, the beliefs became part of who I thought I was, and that version of me needed to stay small.
So I didn’t ask Mr. Protector Part to stop protecting me. I asked him to change jobs. First I thanked him, and meant it. He had been trying to keep me safe since I was a small child, in a family where being small was the right call, and when he came back at fourteen he was doing the only job he had ever had. He did it well, with what he knew. Then I told him what he didn’t know. I’m not the small boy who needed to stay out of my father’s way anymore, or the fourteen-year-old in my stepfather’s house. I’ve survived every rejection on that list and more. Someone turning me down is not a threat to my existence, or even to my safety, and it hasn’t been for a long time.
The real threat now is the self-limiting beliefs. They keep me from putting my work in front of the people it could help, and they put my ability to earn a living, pay the mortgage and support my wife and family at risk. That is a danger worth guarding against, and it’s harder to spot than the one he knows, because it doesn’t come from outside. For fifty years, rejection had often looked enough like the old danger to set him off. So I asked him to learn the difference, and to guard me from the real one: to catch the moment someone’s no starts turning into a verdict about who I am, and to help me question the verdict instead of believing it.
I think he got it. I felt something shift as I wrote, and I had the sense that he could finally see the difference between what he’d been guarding against and what his guarding was costing me. But a pattern fifty years in the making doesn’t resolve in one good morning. I’ll find out what changed the next time a podcast host doesn’t write back, a reader decides the book isn’t for them, or something I’ve written goes out to silence. Those are the moments when he’ll either reach for the old job or try the new one, and understanding why he exists doesn’t do that work for me. Practice does, one rejection at a time.
If you’ve read Chapter 8, you’ll recognize the Five Rs at work in that morning, though not as tidy steps, and not all equally far along in me. Recognition had taken years: learning to see the Part as a protector rather than as me, tracing him back to my early childhood, and seeing why he came back the year of the election. Regulation is the one I still struggle with. When something sets him off, Mr. Protector Part still takes the wheel more often than I’d like; what I’ve gotten better at is noticing when he has and returning more quickly. In my journal that morning nothing had set him off, and I could meet him from a different place than the one he usually finds me in. Meeting a Part when you’re calm is not the same as staying calm when it’s triggered, and it’s worth knowing which one you’re doing.
Relationship was meeting him with appreciation instead of frustration. Re-authoring was the evidence he had never seen, that the boy he was protecting grew up and survived, and the new assignment that came with it. Reintegration isn’t something I get to declare. It happens on the nervous system’s timeline, not mine, and the next rejection will tell me how it’s going.
Most of us have a version of Mr. Protector Part. It might look like keeping quiet in the meeting, not applying for the job, not pitching the idea you’ve been sitting on for a year, or not signing up for the painting class you’ve wanted to take since you were twenty. If you notice yourself staying smaller than you want to be, it’s worth asking what that protector is guarding you from, whether there was a time when it was doing exactly the right job, and whether what sets it off now is danger or only something that looks like it. Start with the thanks. A protector that has been working for decades deserves to have its work understood before it’s asked to change. Then look at the evidence you have now that it never had, and ask what it might protect you from instead.
For fifty years, Mr. Protector Part agreed with the school office: you don’t want to know. Better not to run, better not to ask for the count. I do want to know now. I’m going to keep putting my name on the ballot, people are going to vote however they vote, and I’ve asked him to help me with what needs protecting now: catching the moment the count starts turning into a verdict about who I am.
What would you run for if the count couldn’t tell you who you are?
If you recognize a protector of your own in this, the first chapter of MIND CONTROL is where the work of seeing it begins. About twenty minutes. Free, no email required.
Three essays a week. One letter on Sunday. The Ritual of Return brings the week’s essays together in your inbox. Send me the Sunday letter →